Global appeal v/s Rights of the Urban Poor!


An article published in Hindustan Times this Sunday revealed the results of a recent survey done by the Economist Intelligence Unit called Hot Spots: Benchmarking Global City Competitiveness.  The survey assessed many of the world’s large cities to determine global competitiveness by analyzing how cities fared in terms of their economic strength, physical capital, financial maturity, institutional effectiveness, social and cultural character, human capital, environmental and natural hazards, and global appeal. Through these parameters, the survey defined competitiveness as a city’s ability to attract capital, business, talent, and tourists.  Though the Indian cities surveyed excelled in economic strength, their performance in other categories placed them all in the lower half of cities ranked, with Ahmedabad ranked at number 92 in the world, Bangalore at 79, Mumbai at 70, and Delhi at 68.


Urban experts who were interviewed for the article recommended different actions that Indian cities could take to raise their global appeal; the creation of safe public spaces, the geographical expansion of cities into their suburbs, an expanded political system that would emphasize local politics were some of the main suggestions offered.  That said, none of these experts mentioned the dark underbellies of the solutions they proposed.


Creating public spaces involves clearing out lands where pavement-dwellers and slum-dwellers have made their homes, essentially evicting them.  Expanding cities geographically demands uprooting people and relocating them to less-desirable locations in hopes that these new suburban areas will become more robust overtime.  Empowering local politicians shifts public responsibility onto representatives whose stakes in the decisions on the ground are limited. All of the recommendations presented in the article are idealistic, top-down solutions, executive decisions made by those who will not need to personally endure the day-to-day effects of these reforms. 


When considering how to best address the problems that cities face, agency must come from the urban poor themselves.  People living in cramped, unsanitary, and deprived conditions know how to uplift their situations if they can access the basic resources they need for development.  Rather than aiming to achieve a competitive edge by attracting tourists and business, perhaps cities should define competitiveness as a desire to become successful, to prosper on their own terms.  The urban poor will stand at the core of this movement, as they are the ones who will benefit the most from urban successes.


Tagged: , ,

One thought on “Global appeal v/s Rights of the Urban Poor!

  1. terraurban July 9, 2012 at 8:36 am Reply

    Interestingly at Rio+20 summit, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon quoted and directed that “Local is global and global is local!” .Ban Ki-moon said, explaining that in today’s globalized world, there is little difference between local and federal governments, and therefore cities play an equally important role in achieving sustainability.
    Mayor Marcio Araujo de Lacerda of Belo Horizonte Brazil emphasized the call for better mobilization, more inclusion, and proper recognition of local governments as key actors in sustainability processes. He expressed optimism on the latest agreed text of Rio+20, noting its relatively strong section on sustainable cities, but believes that more can be done to empower local governments.
    Britanny Triffold, winner of Date with History and Rio+20 youth speaker reinforced the importance of local authorities in sustainable development by saying: “We view local governments to be more influential and it is more feasible for them to influence and follow through with our demands more specifically to where we are living! Yes, I do place more faith in the local governments.”
    May be therefore the solution to the ‘Global image’ of our city comes first and foremost an action together taken by the citizens and the urban local bodies towards a more just and equitable development. Appeal only happens when the basics of any city are correct! Like it is said – ‘Think Global, Act Local’

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: